Thursday, September 1, 2005

anslem's ontological argument

ok, so in philosophy class today we talked about anslem's ontological argument for god's existance. it was as follows:

1. we have the concept of god, and in that sense god exists "in the understanding."
2. the concept of "god" is the concept of the greatest conceivable being.
3. real existance is greater than mere existance in the understanding.
4. therefore, god must exist in reality, not just in the understanding.


this of course is just the book's summation of anslem's actual argument, which was long and confusing. ok, now what i think is that this anslem guy is just spouting a bunch of rubbish. why? because by saying that god is greater than anything we can ever think of, aren't we thinking that god is greater than anything we can ever think of? so does that mean that god is greater than the idea that god is greater than anything we can ever think of? and hey! wouldja look at that, we just thought of god being greater than the idea of god being greater than anything we can ever think of! so does that mean that god is greater than the idea that god is greater than the idea that god is greater than anything we can ever think of? this process of thought could go on and on infinitely, so how does this prove that god exists? doesn't this just prove that the human mind is infinite in itself? so how can god be greater than something infinate; what is greater than infinity? i'm not trying to prove that god doesn't exist, i'm just trying to prove that anslem's argument can't prove shit. when i voiced this opinion in class i heard somebody behind me say "woah!" which was pretty funny, but the teacher misunderstood me and thought i was saying something along the lines that the human mind is finite ane cannot conceive the idea of god, which is an argument that some people have made before. no, quite the opposite, after all, we just conceived that god could be greater than what the human mind can comprehend, so how is it we cannot conceive the idea of god?

there was another argument we went over briefly that said that god was perfect, and existence is perfection; therefore god exists. ok, here's what i gotta say about that one: the reality in which we reside is imperfect. so assuming that we exist we must conclude that existance is imperfect. you can't define perfect, there's no such thing (universally there isn't anyway). going back to where i stated that we're assuming that we exist; do we really exist at all? how can we define what is in existance and what isn't? where does fantasy end and reality begin? what if we're just somebody's idea or dream? for example, i'm writing a story. who's to say that the characters in my story aren't real? what if they think they're real, just as we think we're real. and for that matter, are we real? in my story people can do magic, but in our reality people cannot do magic. so what if we're in a story that somebody wrote in a reality where people can't walk? does that make our ability to walk real? does that make my character's ability to do magic real? if something doesn't exist in the creator's world, can it truly exist in the world of their creation? strange, no?

and now on to other matters. this morning in oral interp. we were divided into groups. these are the groups in which we will be critiquing each other's work and stuff, so the teacher had us share our "why do i write" explanations with each other, and in my explanation i told them about how i used to make up stories for my dolls and that one time some of the dolls got caught smoking in the girl's bathroom. this made them all laugh. ^^ then we were supposed to introduce our group to the rest of the class, each of us had to say something about our group. one girl introduced us individually and said that our group's name (we had to choose names) was on hiatus (literally, but it ended up being our actual group name because of it). then i said that all of our interest in writing stemmed from an early interest in reading. i can't remember what the other girl said, but the only guy in our group said that one of us used to make up stories for their dolls, and the first girl, sarah added that one time the dolls got caught smoking in the girls bathroom. i was cracking up as they both said this. it was funny, especially the look on the teacher's face. i made up strange things as a child. i was probably around 10 when i made up the said story, but when i was in pre-school i wrote a book in which our dog ran away and my dad spilled his beer (he was drinking the beer as he was walking the dog). i was 3-years-old at the time, and the teacher even drew a lil' caldecott medal on my book cover (which was made of wallpaper from one of those sample wallpaper books).

so anyway, as soon as i got back to my dorm i started reading my groups' manuscripts. coincidentally, two of the other three group memebers also wrote something fantasy/sci fi. the only difference is that theirs was modern sci fi/fantasy and mine, well, isn't. now all i have to do is critique them.

Wednesday, August 31, 2005

the gameboy conspiricy

yea, that's right, there's a gameboy conspiricy, i tell you! jessie and i have been trying to play final fantasy crystal chronicles together on her gamecube, but it insists that we need to plug in a gameboy advance. so we do, and we have the second player on a regular gamecube controller, but no! we have to have ALL players on hooked up gameboy advance(s) in order to multiplayer mode! it's a conspiricy to get you to buy four gameboy advance(s) and link cables.... *shakes head*

in other news, there's a paper conspiricy at the library, too. i have to take 10 pages of my original writing and bring in 5 copies of it to my oral interp. class tomorrow. well, i don't have a printer, of course, and i don't wanna waste 50 pages of jessie's paper, so i went down to the library to print out copies. first off, i can only print out one copy of the ten pages of my story excerpt from the computer (5 cents a page), so i have to photocopy the rest (10 cents a copy). not only that, but it won't let me use the money i had just put on my student card to pay for the copies (it did for the printer, but not th copier). you have to use change for the copier... seriously, what the hell! i ran 30 cents and 3 pages short, but luckily for me the lady who was copying before me said i could have her last dime that was already in the machine. unfortunately that meant i had to walk back up to the dorms to get a mere 20 cents (i had run out of ones to put in the change machine), then walk all the way back to copy the last page 2 more times...... i need to get myself a printer dammit....

Tuesday, August 30, 2005

Don't Touch Me!

Don't Touch Me!

this was mildly entertaining.

:(

i kinda feel bad. i fell asleep in my philosophy class today, and now i feel terrible about it. it's one think to nap during class in high school, but this is entirely different. i hope the professor doesn't think i'm some kinda bratty person now...

and now i can't think of anything else to post...

Monday, August 29, 2005

crazy weird

ok, so last week john was over and showed jessie and me this website called the facebook, and i was just lookin' around on it a few minutes ago. what's so weird is that i was finding all these people i went to grade school with, and whenever you view somebody's profile it shows you how you're connected to that person (for example: you:john:jessie, you get the idea?). thing is, everybody is so interconnected there. i dunno, i was just thinkin' "damn, this is crazy weird" while viewing...

ok, so i'm just hangin' out here in my dorm room..... again..... waiting till my next class at 5:30. i prolly should be doing the reading assignment, because i think we may be having a quiz over it, but hey, it's not even 3:30 yet! so i'm here on the internet again instead.

speaking of people from gradeschool, on my way to psychology i saw this guy i went to gradeschool with. nothing too exciting: "hi, anne" "hey"; so i guess that means i'm recognizable from gradeschool. i don't think i've changed that much (facially), but jessie says she thinks i've changed enough since freshman year that there's a chance people won't recognize me. eh, whatever...

potentially good news! while i was at work yesterday decorating, thelma (full-time decorator), and rosemary (weekend clerk) were talking about how our department is looking for somebody to replace judy (part-time decorator) when she leaves next month (she's going back to school). and i think it may have been rosemary, who has always been impressed with my decorating skills, who suggested that hey, they should promote anne to part-time decorator (right now i'm just a closer, but sometimes i get to come in and just decorate) and find another closer instead! it's easier to find a closer than it is to find a decorator, she said. thelma agreed. so that would be cool if i got promoted to part-time decorator (no more washing dishes, thank you god!!). if that happened i don't think i'd quit and find another job up here.